Community Chair

Efficiency Ratio – is the measure of credit union’s productivity. The lower the efficiency ratio, the better. A high or rising efficiency ratio means that the credit union is losing a larger share of its income to overhead expenses. A low-efficiency ratio means that operating expenses are a smaller percentage of income. It can be interpreted as how much does it cost the credit union to create $1 of revenue.

The efficiency ratio divides a credit union’s operating expenses by interest income less interest expenses plus non-interest income.

Here is the list of the 50 most efficient credit union (size greater than $500M in asset) as per Call 5300 report for Dec-2019.

Rank CUName State url Efficiency Ratio in Q4-2019 Total Asset (in Millions)
1 STATE FARM IL http://www.statefarmfcu.com 33% 4,289.61
2 SCHLUMBERGER EMPLOYEES TX http://www.secu.slb.com 33% 830.26
3 APCO EMPLOYEES AL HTTP://WWW.APCOCU.ORG 37% 3,006.80
4 FIRST SOUTH FINANCIAL TN HTTP://WWW.FIRSTSOUTH.COM 37% 620.98
5 MERCK EMPLOYEES NJ http://WWW.MERCKCU.COM 40% 1,907.99
6 GREENSTATE IA http://greenstate.org 42% 5,757.17
7 NASA MD HTTP://WWW.NASAFCU.COM 43% 3,110.21
8 GENISYS MI HTTP://WWW.GENISYSCU.ORG 43% 2,847.19
9 HOUSTON POLICE TX HTTP://WWW.HPCU.COOP 44% 751.41
10 EAST TEXAS PROFESSIONAL TX HTTP://WWW.ETPCU.ORG 44% 653.19
11 FREEDOM PA HTTP://WWW.FREEDOMCU.ORG 45% 997.44
12 AUSTIN TELCO TX https://www.atfcu.org 46% 1,819.44
13 POLICE & FIRE PA HTTP://WWW.PFFCU.ORG 47% 5,628.62
14 NAVY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION VA https://www.navyfcu.org/ 47% 111,986.00
15 TINKER OK HTTP://WWW.TINKERFCU.ORG 48% 4,228.68
16 ALL IN AL http://www.allincu.com 49% 1,514.22
17 ROBINS FINANCIAL GA HTTP://WWW.ROBINSFCU.ORG 49% 2,738.62
18 ESL NY http://esl.org 49% 6,813.67
19 REDWOOD CA HTTP://WWW.REDWOODCU.ORG 50% 4,989.06
20 FLORIDA FL HTTP://WWW.FLCU.ORG 50% 1,266.31
21 WINGS FINANCIAL MN HTTP://WWW.WINGSFINANCIAL.COM 50% 5,633.12
22 NAVY ARMY COMMUNITY TX http://www.navyarmyccu.com 50% 3,264.30
23 TEXANS TX HTTP://WWW.TEXANSCU.ORG 50% 1,606.02
24 SCHOOLS FINANCIAL CA HTTP://WWW.SCHOOLS.ORG 51% 2,150.08
25 COAST CENTRAL CA http://www.coastccu.org 51% 1,577.08
26 TYNDALL FL HTTP://WWW.TYNDALL.ORG 51% 1,634.28
27 MAYO EMPLOYEES MN HTTP://WWW.MAYOCREDITUNION.ORG 51% 1,026.12
28 SELF RELIANCE NY NY http://www.selfrelianceny.org 51% 1,388.54
29 LANDMARK WI https://www.landmarkcu.com 51% 4,463.28
30 PIMA AZ HTTP://WWW.PIMAFCU.ORG 52% 600.66
31 F & A CA http://WWW.FAFCU.ORG 52% 1,752.79
32 EXCITE CA http://www.excitecu.org 52% 513.82
33 SAFE 1 CA HTTP://SAFE1.ORG 52% 652.81
34 DFCU FINANCIAL MI HTTP://WWW.DFCUFINANCIAL.COM 52% 4,903.18
35 ELGA MI HTTP://WWW.ELGACU.COM 52% 794.13
36 WRIGHT-PATT CREDIT UNION, INC. OH HTTP://WPCU.COOP 52% 5,091.93
37 SOUTHWEST AIRLINES TX http://www.swacu.org 52% 588.66
38 GOLDENWEST UT HTTP://WWW.GWCU.ORG 52% 1,742.04
39 MISSION CA HTTP://WWW.MISSIONFED.COM 53% 3,856.22
40 DADE COUNTY FL http://www.dcfcu.org 53% 784
41 MIDFLORIDA FL HTTP://WWW.MIDFLORIDA.COM 53% 4,422.01
42 SUNCOAST FL http://www.suncoastcreditunion.com 53% 10,534.61
43 DUPACO COMMUNITY IA http://www.dupaco.com 53% 1,888.19
44 IDAHO CENTRAL ID http://www.iccu.com 53% 5,070.73
45 ABOUND KY http://www.Aboundcu.com 53% 1,660.16
46 SRP SC HTTP://WWW.SRPFCU.ORG 53% 1,067.08
47 ALLSOUTH SC HTTPS://WWW.ALLSOUTH.ORG 53% 897.98
48 EASTMAN TN http://www.ecu.org 53% 5,099.59
49 EECU TX http://www.eecu.org 53% 2,504.83
50 NEIGHBORHOOD TX http://www.myncu.com 53% 810.06

 

4766195266?profile=RESIZE_710x

And here is the list of 50 least efficient credit unions (size greater than $500M in asset) as per Call 5300 report for Dec-2019.

Rank  CUName State url Efficiency Ratio Total Asset (in Millions)
1 EVANGELICAL CHRISTIAN CA HTTP://WWW.ECCU.ORG 110% 715.9
2 MUNICIPAL NY HTTP://WWW.NYMCU.ORG 96% 3,052.27
3 ALIGN MA HTTP://WWW.ALIGNCU.COM 86% 641.38
4 LIBERTY BAY MA HTTP://WWW.LIBERTYBAYCU.ORG 86% 669.86
5 CHEVRON CA http://www.chevronfcu.org 85% 3,575.30
6 MEMBERS CHOICE TX HTTP://WWW.MCCU.COM 85% 609.03
7 XCEED FINANCIAL CA https://www.xfcu.org 84% 884.29
8 THRIVENT WI HTTP://WWW.THRIVENTCU.COM 83% 629.55
9 KEYPOINT CA https://www.kpcu.com 82% 1,295.12
10 SANTA CLARA COUNTY CA HTTP://WWW.SCCFCU.ORG 81% 807.1
11 1ST NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CA http://www.1stnorcalcu.org/ 81% 728.22
12 POLISH NATIONAL MA HTTP://WWW.PNCU.COM 81% 615.32
13 ARDENT PA http://www.ardentcu.org 81% 719.48
14 DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE DC HTTP://WWW.DOCFCU.ORG 80% 529.37
15 DIRECT MA http://www.direct.com 80% 757.77
16 CREDIT HUMAN TX https://www.credithuman.com 80% 3,210.47
17 BLACKHAWK COMMUNITY WI HTTP://WWW.BHCCU.ORG 80% 619.88
18 ALOHA PACIFIC HI https://alohapacific.com 79% 968.34
19 ST. MARY'S MA HTTP://WWW.STMARYSCU.ORG 79% 877.85
20 FIREFIGHTERS FIRST CA HTTP://WWW.FIREFIGHTERSFIRSTCU.ORG 78% 1,488.66
21 NORTHROP GRUMMAN CA http://www.ngfcu.us 78% 1,194.17
22 FRONTWAVE CA http://www.frontwavecu.com 78% 877.46
23 ATLANTIC REGIONAL ME http://atlanticfcu.com 78% 748.76
24 SANDIA LABORATORY NM http://www.slfcu.org 78% 2,634.47
25 FINANCIAL PARTNERS CA HTTP://WWW.FPCU.ORG 77% 1,503.28
26 SOUTHLAND CA HTTP://WWW.SOUTHLANDCU.ORG 77% 820.08
27 ELEVATIONS CO HTTP://WWW.ELEVATIONSCU.COM 77% 2,213.51
28 121 FINANCIAL FL http://www.121fcu.org 77% 541.95
29 SELFRELIANCE IL HTTP://WWW.SELFRELIANCE.COM 77% 622.23
30 RTN MA HTTP://WWW.RTN.ORG 77% 904.42
31 LAFAYETTE MD HTTP://WWW.LFCU.ORG 77% 681.42
32 TEAM ONE MI HTTP://WWW.TEAMONECU.ORG 77% 569.35
33 MYPOINT CA http://www.mypointcu.com 76% 527.83
34 INSIGHT FL HTTP://INSIGHTCREDITUNION.COM 76% 553.07
35 HOOSIER HILLS IN HTTP://WWW.HOOSIERHILLS.COM 76% 609.33
36 GREYLOCK MA https://www.greylock.org 76% 1,255.43
37 CITY & COUNTY MN HTTP://WWW.CCCU.COM 76% 893.59
38 POLISH & SLAVIC NY HTTPS://WWW.PSFCU.COM 76% 2,068.24
39 SEATTLE METROPOLITAN WA HTTP://WWW.SMCU.COM 76% 831.54
40 THE POLICE CA HTTP://WWW.THEPOLICECU.ORG 75% 938.86
41 WESTERRA CO HTTP://WESTERRACU.COM 75% 1,571.77
42 HFS HI http://HFSFCU.ORG 75% 595.9
43 ANDIGO IL HTTP://WWW.ANDIGO.ORG 75% 850.1
44 LA CAPITOL LA http://www.lacapfcu.org 75% 512.69
45 LAKE TRUST MI HTTP://WWW.LAKETRUST.ORG 75% 1,917.93
46 BELLWETHER COMMUNITY NH HTTP://WWW.BCCU.ORG 75% 529.52
47 AFFINITY NJ http://www.affinityfcu.org 75% 3,529.01
48 GENERATIONS COMMUNITY TX http://www.mygenfcu.org 75% 551.81
49 PACIFIC SERVICE CA HTTP://WWW.PACIFICSERVICE.ORG 74% 1,166.91
50 PROVIDENT CA http://providentcu.org 74% 2,795.78

 

4766550069?profile=RESIZE_710x

It would be interesting to hear your views on why some of these credit unions are so efficient? Is it because they are doing more digitally than traditional ways like branches? What is the maturity level of process automation in these credit unions?

For the credit unions, which are on the other side of the spectrum, what are they doing to bring down their efficiency ratio within reasonable limits? Are there specific areas that they are looking to invest in?

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of CULytics Community to add comments!

Join CULytics Community

 

advantedge
altair
ibi
arka
trellance
coopfs
dfa
wherescape
alkami
prismacampaigns
marquis
aiq
totex
cnet
datava
aun
cinch
know

Related Post

 

Ad Unit Settings






Ad Url Settings

 

api-lead-approach
the-amazon-lending-experience
executing-advanced-analytics-do-s-and-don-t
lending-transformation-old-vs-new
data-journey-building-strong-analytical-practices
4-step-iterative-process-building-a-relevant-analytics-practice
significant-measures-towards-new-normal
building-a-strong-analytics-practice-recipe-for-success
data-warehouse-evaluation-and-implementation
explainable-ai-trust-and-transparency
forecasting
top-50-members-using-transactional-website-jun-2020
top-50-cus-with-highest-and-lowest-efficiency-june-2020
importance-of-financial-risk-management
secret-sauce-for-long-term-sustainable-business-intelligence-succ
top-pfm-technologies
secret-sauce-for-long-term-sustainable-business-intelligence-succ
top-pfm-technologies
data-warehouse-and-bi-technologies-opportunities-challenges
top-chatbot-technologies
keys-to-building-an-effective-branch-or-atm-network
top-50-credit-unions-with-highest-and-lowest-accounts-per-member
lowest-and-highest-net-income-per-branch
marketing-holy-grail
top-50-most-and-least-delinquent-credit-unions
modern-marketing-technologies
incremental-low-cost-data-driven-wins
power-of-storytelling
the-cost-of-not-investing-in-data-governance
questions-you-should-ask-before-investing-in-data-warehouse
learnings-from-new-data-based-on-auto-loan-pricing
5-questions-you-need-to-ask-before-investing-in-data-governance
digital-marketing-maturity-models-for-credit-unions
marketing-expense-per-member
top-2-reasons-that-are-holding-credit-unions-back-when-they-are-i
using-data-analytics-to-manage-lending-complexity-while-driving-h
5-reasons-your-credit-union-should-invest-in-data-and-digital-now
top-50-most-and-least-efficient-credit-unions
retail-financial-services-outlook-during-covid-19
use-of-operational-analytics-to-mitigate-the-impact-of-covid-19
top-50-credit-unions-based-on-asset-size
cu-peer-comparison-dashboard
cu-peer-benchmark
all-about-machine-learning-engineering
top-web-design-trends
most-important-social-media-marketing-trends
state-of-digital-marketing-maturing-in-credit-unions
top-kpis-for-email-marketing
data-cloud-and-the-digital-transformation-imperative
digital-trinity-and-you
phases-of-financial-industry
analytics-roundtable-workshop
invitation-to-join-digital-transformation-hub
analytics-in-the-credit-union-business
value-of-member-centricity-and-analytics-in-the-growth-of-cus
all-about-membership-analytics
top-fraud-management-technologies
getting-started-with-your-data-analytics-journey
explore-vizualization-for-credit-unions
investment-in-website-personalization-technologies
data-analytics-supporting-cu-s-first-member-philosophy
loyalty-rewards-and-retention-technologies
member-experience-analytics
channel-analytics-and-its-importance
project-portfolio-management-technologies
investment-in-self-service-data-preparation-technologies
self-service-data-preparation-technologies
new-frontier-in-customer-experience-management
role-of-marketing-analytics-in-credit-unions
important-aspects-of-consumer-lending-analytics
kpis-on-website-analytics
journey-towards-bank-less-banking
investment-in-crm-technologies
top-omni-channel-vendors
conversational-banking-solutions
/top-kpis-for-chief-information-officer
mistakes-to-avoid-when-implementing-a-omnichannel-member
top-things-to-consider-when-building-dashboards
making-digital-marketing-more-agile-through-tag-managers
cecl-solution-providers
mistakes-to-avoid-while-implementing-marketing-automation
p2p-payment-integrated-solutions
kpis-for-social-media-tracking
kpis-for-human-resources-management
investment-in-fintechs-should-or-should-not
top-kpis-for-online-banking
investment-in-marketing-automation-technologies
investment-in-e-signature-technologies-should-or-should-not
tips-and-tricks-to-a-successful-bi-program
kpis-for-credit-card-business
kpis-for-digital-marketing
kpis-for-consumer-lending
hot-topics-for-credit-union-data-leaders
kpis-for-debt-collections
kpis-for-finance
website-personalization-tools
data-integration-technologies
robotic-process-automation-tools
why-data-analytics-initiatives-fail
electronic-signature-softwares
data-governance-tools-for-credit-unions
digital-and-mobile-banking-technologies
report-inconsistencies-are-frustrating
is-your-culture-ready-for-data-analytics
three-big-data-myths
turning-transaction-data-into-a-goldmine-a-becu-case-study
call-for-presentation-for-2019-credit-union-analytics-summit-is-n
top-10-keys-to-successful-data-analytics-practice
credit-union-chooses-accountscore-for-open-banking-transaction-da
how-much-do-you-spend-to-serve-a-customer
marketing-automation-technologies-for-credit-union
alexa-ask-first-abilene-fcu-for-my-balance
dataweb-content-management-technologies-for-credit-unions
efficiency-ratio
web-analytics-technologies
data-warehousing-software-for-banks
customer-experience-software
the-best-kept-secret-for-credit-union-data-analytics
mark-sievewright-on-technology-trends
naveen-jain-on-credit-union-analytics-summit-2018
why-analytics-doesn-t-make-a-difference-by-gary-angel
cuas2018-harnessing-the-right-data
build-a-financial-phone-assistant-for-your-credit-union-in-3-step
2018-culytics-analytics-challenge-winner
update-from-naveen
error-resolution
benefits-of-conversational-apps
who-are-your-most-valuable-members-part-1
how-alexa-can-help-your-credit-union
top-10-kpis-for-measuring-retail-channel-performance
how-much-is-too-much-personalization
top-10-kpis-for-measuring-contact-center-efficiency
pressure-on-margins-for-auto-loans-indirect-auto-loans-declining
best-business-intelligence-technologies-for-credit-unions
establishing-a-thriving-data-analytics-practice-is-a-journey
educational-presentations-from-the-2017-axfi-conference
modelling-alternatives-for-cecl-a-deep-future-analytics-study
data-analytics-use-cases-for-credit-unions-infographic
data-analytics-opportunities-in-credit-union-business
loan-application-analytics-with-cufx
machine-learning-delivers-great-consumer-experiences
deep-insights-of-credit-union-members-data-with-machine-learning
web-analytics-reporting-tips-for-credit-unions
big-data-strategy-roadmap-our-data-journey
webinar-framework-for-member-focused-decision-making
too-many-regulations-hurt-credit-union-members
digital-marketing-automation-solutions
online-banking-boom
transformation-transactions-to-relationships
top-dispute-management-technologies
2020-retail-trends
future-of-artificial-intelligence
2020-culytics-summit-attendee-dashboard
repositioning-the-role-of-marketing
marketing-automation-a-step-towards-marketing-transformation
strategic-agility
using-data-to-navigate-through-the-new-normal
digital-transformation-bcu
highest-and-lowest-new-loan-balances-per-branch-as-of-jun-2020
-new-members-ratio-as-of-june-2020
cus-with-highest-and-lowest-loan-grants-per-member-june-2020
self-service-data-preparation-technologies
highest-and-lowest-marketing-expense-per-member-june-2020
the-amazon-lending-experience
api-lead-approach
4-step-iterative-process-building-a-relevant-analytics-practice
data-journey-building-strong-analytical-practices
post-election-the-cu-outlook
most-and-least-delinquent-credit-unions-sept-2020
leveraging-ach-data-to-produce-real-outcomes
member-engagement-scores-benefits
member-engagement-key-to-serve-the-best
story-of-james-an-intelligence-transformation
executive-kpis-the-pulse-of-the-organization
untangling-member-journey
onboarding-strategy-to-deliver-success
the-importance-of-digital-technologies
top-interactive-financial-calculators
using-artificial-intelligence-to-improve-your-productivity
organizational-transformation-to-drive-growth
multi-year-journey-through-data-transformation
top-50-cus-with-the-highest-and-lowest-member-per-branch
digital-transformation-lessons-through-the-eyes-of-a-ceo
organizational-readiness-for-digital-transformation
ruthless-prioritization-to-do-more-to-learn-more-and-to-earn-more
performance-measures-for-digital-services
analytical-maturity-journey-towards-growth
less-is-more-the-necessity-of-focus-for-strategic-success
solving-the-crm-mrm-puzzle
insights-driven-messaging-member-and-product-onboarding
performance-measures-for-marketing
data-insights-that-drive-member-product-innovation
solving-the-crm-mrm-puzzle
the-agility-flywheel-a-strategy-that-never-goes-out-of-the-way
artificial-intelligence-as-a-playing-field-for-credit-unions
performance-measures-for-call-centers
top-automl-technologies
performance-measures-for-lending
building-business-case-for-data-analytics
driving-innovation-and-change
data-analyze-decide-and-create
digital-readiness-important-steps-to-achieve
digital-readiness-important-steps-to-achieve
enabling-credit-unions-with-ai
culytics-virtual-summit-2022-a-resounding-success
culytics-virtual-summit-2022-day-1
digital-banking-roundtable
digital-marketing-roundtable
transformative-lessons-from-a-chief-digital-officer
data-analytics-roundtable-mar-11
rewind-2022-culytics-day-key-highlights
data-analytics-team-roles
data-warehouse-development
data-analytics-team-size
is-your-data-analytics-program-not-delivering-results
active-deposit-management-for-profitable-growth
data-modeling
maximize-your-success-with-2023-CULytics-summit
biggest-opportunities-for-credit-unions
should-ceos-attend-the-culytics-summit
the-cost-of-a-wrong-decision
biggest-roadblocks-in-becoming-data-driven
a-journey-for-all-organizational-maturity-levels
maximize-your-data-analytics-checkup
navigating-the-data-analytics-landscape
improving-data-literacy
why-credit-union-leaders-should-invest-in-their-teams
why-credit-unions-should-not-invest-in-building-predictive-models
why-should-measure-the-success-of-data-analytics-program
cost-of-choosing-the-wrong-data-analytics-technology-stack
why-data-analytics-strategy-focus-on-supply-and-demand-side
kpis-to-measure-the-success-of-data-analytics-program
data-analytics-for-credit-union-branch-heads
data-organizing-principles
top-data-warehouse-storage-technologies
discover-the-hidden-truth-behind-watermelon-kpis
unveiling-the-hidden-dangers-of-cobra-effect-on-kpis
are-you-accurately-interpreting-your-kpi
unmasking-biases-a-guide-to-data-analysis-and-kpi-definition
uncover-the-power-of-proxy-kpis
unraveling-the-hidden-impact-of-sampling-bias-in-credit-unions
bi-department-structure
hidden-impact-of-confirmation-bias-in-credit-unions
getting-executive-attention-for-your-data-analytics-program
uncovering-biases-in-data-preprocessing
navigating-missing-data-in-credit-unions
navigating-sampling-bias-in-cu
unleash-the-power-of-real-time-data-use-cases
how-confirmation-bias-impacts-cus
breaking-down-selection-bias-in-credit-unions
unmasking-reporting-bias
elevate-your-cu-with-data-analytics-expertise
understanding-and-tackling-volunteer-bias-in-credit-unions
time-period-bias-in-credit-union
overcoming-biases-in-credit-unions
embracing-the-future-fast-future-fundamentals-program-equips-cred
unlock-growth-and-efficiency-credit-unions-guide-to-generative-ai
how-better-data-and-behavioral-biometrics-can-help-credit-unions-
harnessing-the-power-of-data-in-credit-unions
leveraging-third-party-data-a-strategic-guide-for-credit-unions
unlocking-member-insights-how-cus-can-leverage-third-party-data
enhancing-customer-experience-through-third-party-data
third-party-data-integration-techniques-and-technologies
the-future-of-lending-third-party-data-role-in-credit-decisioning
how-third-party-information-shapes-cu-strategies
using-data-to-improve-access-to-credit-for-low-income-members
designing-financial-products-for-low-income-members-using-data
measuring-and-enhancing-the-impact-of-support-programs
data-governance-why-selling-internally-is-important
selling-data-governance-in-your-credit-union
building-a-business-case-and-engaging-stakeholders
creating-a-data-governance-roadmap-and-executing-it
measuring-and-demonstrating-the-impact-of-data-governance
sustaining-momentum-keeping-data-governance-a-priority
overcoming-challenges-in-transaction-data-analysis-credit-unions
empowering-members-through-transaction-data
how-credit-unions-leverage-transaction-data-best-practices
unlocking-financial-independence-the-power-of-transaction-data
the-power-of-transaction-data-enrichment
avoid-financial-reputation-and-member-trust-issues
introduction-to-model-risk-management
week-1-mrm-a-practitioner-s-approach
week-2-guide-to-identifying-and-maintaining-models
survey-insights-navigating-mrm-in-credit-unions
week-3-application-of-mrm-insights-to-sound-model-development-eff
unlocking-the-secrets-to-attracting-gen-y-and-z
creating-a-seamless-member-experience-for-gen-y-and-gen-z
data-analytics-maturity-assessment-report
marketing-to-gen-y-and-z-strategies-that-work-for-credit-unions
the-imperative-of-engaging-millennials-and-gen-z
cu-build-lasting-relationships-with-gen-z-financial-literacy
how-social-responsibility-drives-gen-z-membership
loyalty-programs-that-work-keeping-gen-y-and-z-members-engaged
insights-on-engaging-millennials-and-gen-z-at-credit-union
ai-driven-member-experience
streamlining-operations-with-ai
innovation-and-member-inclusion-in-ai-credit-risk-models
ai-risk-management-enhancing-fraud-detection-and-cybersecurity
how-ai-is-transforming-data-analytics-for-credit-union
overcoming-ai-adoption-challenges-in-credit-unions
the-state-of-ai-in-credit-unions-survey-insights
creating-a-culture-of-innovation
building-the-foundation
closing-the-talent-gap